Mohammad AskarPublic working copy · medical review pending

Glaucoma risk and early detection · 161

Open-angle glaucoma: risk, early detection and the 2024 S2e guideline

Ask who needs examination, what a suspicious result means and when to repeat a negative screen. Distinguish the strength of a recommendation from the underlying evidence level.

Public working copy · medical review pending. Source, translation and medical checks remain open. Read the limitations in the text and references. These educational materials do not replace individual medical assessment. Published: 2026-11-18T19:45:52+01:00. Internal project references lead to this notice. They are not publicly accessible primary sources; the source limitations remain stated in the text.

Risk factors guide assessment, not a glaucoma diagnosis. The German screening intervals concern people without known glaucoma; manifest disease and diagnosed ocular hypertension need individual follow-up.

Terminology and draft status

Terminology review is not complete. Selected actual WHO UMD queries and their limits are recorded in terminology.md; they do not approve the whole translation.

01Define the clinical question and the evidence

Open-angle glaucoma involves progressive neuroretinal rim and retinal nerve fibre layer (RNFL) loss with corresponding visual-field damage. Early symptoms may be absent; risk assessment, detection, treatment and follow-up all contribute to care, so risk quantification is not the only means of preventing disability. 1 2

The original symptom figures, 26% without symptoms and 54% reporting blurred patches despite field loss, describe selected patients and definitions. Its 8-fold association with no eye examination within 2 years is not a causal guarantee that a fixed interval prevents blindness; the underlying studies remain to be appraised. 1

The DOG/BVA S2e update dated 3 March 2024 addresses adult risk and early detection, largely using populations of European ancestry; it does not set management for known glaucoma or diagnosed ocular hypertension. A strong A recommendation can coexist with evidence level 3 and expert consensus; Oxford 2011 levels and A/B/0 grades answer different questions. 2

02Keep incidence, prevalence and ancestry distinct

The original summarises 5-year incidence at age 40–80 as 0.5–1.5%, with Blue Mountains/Rotterdam about 0.5–0.6%, Salzburg-Moorfields 1.0% over 5 years and northern Sweden 0.9% per year. These heterogeneous ages, endpoints and periods cannot be pooled or converted into one annual risk; source-specific primary reports remain needed. 1

Prevalence increases with age; the original 2.0–2.5-fold increase per decade from age 40 and 1.3-fold male prevalence are group associations, not individual forecasts. First-degree family history is associated with about 2.0–3.0-fold risk, but reporting and ascertainment affect the estimate. 1 2

The original approximately 3-fold estimate for darker-skinned populations and earlier onset, and rising risk with age in Latin American populations, need population-specific context. Skin colour is an imprecise proxy for ancestry and social factors; do not infer an individual genetic risk or a universal coefficient from appearance. 1 2

03Interpret pressure and disc findings in context

Intraocular pressure (IOP) is the established treatment target, but high IOP is not synonymous with glaucoma. OHTS randomised 1636 selected patients aged 40–80 without glaucomatous damage, with IOP 24–32 mmHg in one eye and 21–32 in the other. At 60 months estimated glaucoma incidence was 9.5% with observation versus 4.4% with medication: HR 0.40, 95% CI 0.27–0.59. 1 3

The original 9% for every eye ≥24 mmHg overgeneralises and rounds the trial. Its 9.5% is a Kaplan–Meier estimate, not the raw 89/819=10.9% proportion; open treatment, masked endpoint assessment, attrition and allocation deviations matter. The CCT-adjustment study concerns risk prediction, not tonometer accuracy; central corneal thickness (CCT) does not justify a universal corrected-IOP formula. 3 4

Cup-to-disc ratio (CDR) ≥0.6 at an average-sized disc or inter-eye asymmetry ≥0.2 increases suspicion; the latter LR 3.9–4.1 is a diagnostic likelihood ratio, not a future-risk multiplier. Disc haemorrhage original 7.5-fold refers to prevalent association, not guaranteed progression; disc size, rim, fields and imaging must be assessed. 1 2

Myopia of magnitude ≥4 dioptres, conventionally ≤−4 D, and pseudoexfoliation (PEX) deserve closer assessment. Original estimates 2.3-fold for myopia and 4–6-fold for PEX depend on population and design and should not be multiplied together as an individual risk score. 1 2

04Ask about the route and preparation of steroids

Topical ocular, intravitreal and systemic steroids can raise IOP. The original up to 79% after 2.1 mg fluocinolone is a historical preparation- and definition-specific estimate; it does not describe every current implant, steroid response or glaucoma incidence. 1 2

The guideline discusses inhaled high doses, historically >4 puffs for at least 3 months, especially with family history. Different inhalers deliver different doses; this is not a safe no-risk threshold. Its intranasal review found no clinically important group increase, which does not prove zero individual risk or justify changing systemic treatment without coordination. 1 2

The original diabetes/hypertension associations of 1.16–1.4 require study-specific interpretation. Shared age and vascular factors, ascertainment and more frequent examinations can confound associations; neither condition proves a glaucomatous optic neuropathy. 1 2

05Offer screening with realistic expectations

DOG/BVA recommends offering screening from age 40, including binocular disc examination and IOP; recommendations 4-3 and 4-4 are strong but have evidence level 3. The historical 64% sensitivity/96% specificity estimate has selection/definition limits, including classifying IOP <18 mmHg as healthy; it is not universal test performance. 2

The Swedish screening follow-up reported blindness RR 0.52 over about 20 years after one screen at age 50–80. This observational follow-up is not the randomised EMGT treatment effect or proof that screening halves every individual risk. Discuss false positives, missed disease and the need to confirm a result. 1 2

A single IOP value cannot exclude OHT or glaucoma. The cited 5.3–6.9 mmHg between-day variation concerns a selected measurement series, not a universal instrument error. Suspicion leads to repeated IOP, perimetry, structural assessment, gonioscopy and pachymetry as appropriate before a treatment decision. 1 2

06Use intervals as consensus guidance, then confirm the diagnosis

The interval table preserves the four original risk groups. These are 2024 German expert-consensus screening intervals after excluding glaucoma, not a schedule for symptomatic patients or established disease. Relevant additional factors include first-degree family history, myopia magnitude ≥4 D, ancestry context, IOP 22–25 mmHg interpreted with CCT, borderline CDR/asymmetry and prolonged ocular/systemic steroids. 2

The original quick-review A/B labels are retained as export labels, not certified as separate recommendations for each association. The guideline bases intervals on combined risk and age; men do not receive a different interval solely because their average prevalence is higher. Explain a positive screen, confirm or exclude disease, document the next visit and individualise when necessary. 1 2

Use intervals as consensus guidance, then confirm the diagnosis
Risk after excluding glaucomaAge 40–59 yearsAge ≥60 years
No additional risk factor5 years2–3 years
1 additional factor2–3 years1 year
≥2 additional factors1 year1 year
PEX or applanation IOP >25 mmHgAt least annually; clinical findings may require soonerAt least annually; clinical findings may require sooner
Use intervals as consensus guidance, then confirm the diagnosis
FactorOriginal estimate and interpretationOriginal LoEOriginal grade labelClinical consequence and limit
Age2.0–2.5× per decade, prevalence1AUse age and total risk, not a personal probability.
Male sex1.3× prevalence1—No separate interval solely for sex.
IOP / OHT ≥24 mmHg (original)Original 9%; selected OHTS 9.5% vs 4.4% at 5 years1ATrial eligibility matters; not all OHT needs identical treatment.
PEX4.0–6.0× association2AOriginal annual screen; known disease has its own follow-up.
Myopia magnitude ≥4 D2.3×, study-specific2BCorrect sign: usually ≤−4 D; combine risk.
First-degree family history2.0–3.0× association2AAscertainment and relatives matter.
Ancestry context (original darker skin)Original 3.0×, not an individual coefficient1BOriginal consider from age 30; consensus and population limits.
CDR asymmetry ≥0.2LR about 4.01ADiagnostic likelihood, not future incidence.
Disc haemorrhage7.5× prevalent association2AInvestigate; neither specific proof nor certain progression.
Inhaled steroidsDose-dependent; historical >4 puffs/≥3 months2BPreparation and family history matter; not a universal safe cutoff.
What are the main learning points?

Risk factors guide assessment, not a glaucoma diagnosis. The German screening intervals concern people without known glaucoma; manifest disease and diagnosed ocular hypertension need individual follow-up.

When is assessment urgent?

Sudden visual loss, severe eye pain, new field loss or marked pressure elevation needs prompt assessment rather than waiting for the next screening date.

References and access status

  1. 1
    Immutable original export; S2e risk and early-detection lecture; examiner role unverified

    Complete export read; original attribution and any recording/transcript or appointment not independently verified.

  2. 2
    DOG/BVA S2e 045-015, 3 March 2024

    Selected extracted original PDF text read 15 November 2026: scope p1, incidence table p8, selected PEX/prevalence p13–14, steroids and disc findings p16–18, recommendations and intervals p19–27. Not the complete 34-page report or all cited studies; source table layout needs image confirmation.

  3. 3
    OHTS 2002; PMID 12049574

    Historical full-text appraisal from review 005 on 2–6 October 2026 and Issue 161 notes reused; not newly read. Open treatment and masked endpoint assessment distinguished.

  4. 4
    Brandt et al. CCT-adjusted IOP and OHTS prediction. 2012; PMID 21705084

    Historical review 005 full-text appraisal reused, with complete-case and delayed-CCT limits. Risk-model discrimination is not measurement accuracy; no new full-text claim.